Emmy Squared Pizza: Williamsburg. Brooklyn

This place is a spot. It was incredibly busy and keeping the staff running, but they were the nicest most gracious people all around. TJ was the man. The cheesy garlic sticks blew our minds, and the pizza was excellent. Can't rate this place higher.

Erik

3 months ago en

I love Emmys and Emily's, been to a few locations but I feel the food at this location is slightly worse than the others. Burger is less juicy and flavorful while the pizza is way too wet and oversalted. Not bad but not at the same standard as the other ones.

Jonathan

4 months ago en

It would be five star if the number of taps they had matched the number of beers they actually serve. Alas, it does not and because of that I ding this place one star which honestly otherwise is one of my favorite places to eat in NYC. Glorious food, truly glorious. Amazing greasy, cheese to the edge and crispy Detroit-Style Pizza. The Colony Squared is my go to. The Big Matt is a great burger, and the waffle fries shame a national chicken chain. The fried chicken is divine. It truly is a wondrous place, save for the beer selection.

David

11 months ago en

Went on a late afternoon Saturday…other than our table of two…there was a family of three…so it wasnt busy at all…there was music with mostly nicki minaj playing explicit lyrics…so it was weird to realize that there was a child there while the nicki was rapping about her “thing”…for drinks, I ordered a whiskey sour and my buddy ordered sprite…it took 15 minutes for our drinks to come out…the things that confused me was that i didnt get a whiskey sour…i got a glass of whiskey on the rocks…which i didnt mind but why would it take that long for something that comes straight from the bottle…both the sprite and the whiskey…the bartender was moving around doing things so i thought my drink was being made…with just two tables being occupied, our drinks shouldn’t have taken that long…the thing that saves this review of this place is that the waitress was extremely helpful and knowledgeable about the menu…the pizza was ok but the burger is where it shined but they dont ask for the temperature of the beef because it comes out medium/medium rare by “default”…so if youre particular about the temperature of your burger patty you have to proactively let them know…waffle fries are crunchy and well seasoned…overall, it was an ok experience.

Joseph

11 months ago en

Tiffany made our night! Not only was the food amazing, but our bar tender, Tiffany, kept us entertained for hours. Such a great place to spend a weekend night. Thank you everyone!

Mackenzie

11 months ago en

Had a great dinner for a friends birthday here! Stephanie was our server and took great care of us! Great pizza and drinks

Patrick

11 months ago en

Went last night for a friends birthday which was amazing! Our server Stephanie was awesome, as were all of the other staff. And the food was incredible. All in all for tons of food we spent around 70pp including gratuity with lots of leftovers for everyone.

Brianne

11 months ago en

We came after our friends finished the half marathon and Stephanie helped us. We had a really good pizza with pesto and tomato sauce and our server Stephanie was sooooo sweet and attentive,she made a great playlist and we had a great time! Such a vibe ,Def coming back

Alina

11 months ago en

Food here was fire the pizza hit different. Me and my husband from cali. Make sure to check out Ariel he is the best, helpful and sweet. Love this place!!!!!!

Renee

1 year ago en